Twenty-five years ago, Craig Zoberis and his wife had a white chocolate mousse wedding cake from Toni's Patisserie & Café. A couple of weeks before an early anniversary celebration this fall, Toni Cox made the top tier again. This time Zoberis was also one of her bakery's three new owners, as The Hinsdalean reported on Sept. 30.
That sale is one of several this year. Over the past eleven months, a run of downtown Hinsdale properties has passed from longtime owners to Hinsdale residents. The bakery on Washington Street changed hands. So did a group of buildings around First and Washington. Every Saturday on the fall calendar, from the Sidewalk Sale to Fall Family Fest's trick-or-treat route, takes place on those blocks. For most of the new owners, the holiday season will be their first full test.
A 32-Year Bakery Heads Into Its First Holiday Rush Under New Owners
Toni Cox and her husband, Paul Pell, opened Toni's in Hinsdale 32 years ago. Earlier this year they sold it to Zoberis, Mark Konieczka and Tom Wake, all Hinsdale residents. The café is at 51 S. Washington St. Zoberis told The Hinsdalean he first spotted the listing in November through Eatz, a broker that sells restaurants. He recognized the business from the description alone. An earlier buyer's deal fell through in the first week of January, and the broker then called him.
The menu stays the same. Cox's recipes were part of the sale, and she described them in the same Hinsdalean story as "Everything from hand-written to typed up to in the computer system," some carrying stains "like an old cookbook." Cox is staying on for the transition, and Steven Rennau is continuing as director of operations.
The owners say they plan no immediate changes. One thing may change later. The café has served only wine and beer, and the owners told The Hinsdalean they had applied for a new village liquor license and expected it this month. Konieczka's comment on the possibilities was "Perhaps there are bloody Marys in the future."
Timing is the bigger issue. "The fourth quarter is always a huge thing for us and a lot of work," Cox told the paper. Downtown's biggest crowds of the year arrive in exactly that quarter, starting this Saturday.
One Block Southwest Of The Bakery, Five Buildings Have Changed Hands
The other big change is a short walk away. Pete Tortorello has lived in Hinsdale for 20 years, and his company, Fairfield Properties, has bought five downtown buildings since November 2025. They sit on or near the southwest corner of First and Washington streets. According to The Hinsdalean's Sept. 23 profile, the plan is updated street-level retail with renovated apartments above. Here is what's happening at each address:
- 11-21 E. First St. This was his first purchase, in November 2025. It houses 10 Friends, Sweet William and Blue Mercury on the ground floor, with apartments and offices above, including his own.
- 102 S. Washington St. John Papenhausen built it in 1888 for his tailoring business. It was the only commercial building on the south side of First Street at the time. Alixandra Blue is on the garden level and Studio W. is on the first floor. A two-floor, 2,025-square-foot, three-bedroom "Owners Unit" with a view from the turret window is listed at $7,000 a month.
- 8-10 W. First St. Tortorello calls it the "yellow house." It is getting new gray siding plus HVAC and electrical upgrades. When the work is done, it will house Frame Bridge, a national online custom-framing company.
- The one-story building behind 8-10 W. First. This 700-square-foot former salon is getting a bay window, skylights and a door moved to line up with the walkway to First Street. It is listed at $4,000 a month.
- 104-106 S. Washington St. The second-floor offices above My Eye Doctor will become four one-bedroom apartments of 670 to 840 square feet as office leases run out.
The small rear building could matter most for everyday life downtown. Tortorello said the parking pad next to it could become a paver-brick patio for the right tenant. "It could be a food use. It could be retail. It could be anything," he told The Hinsdalean, adding, "I think we need more food options for quick bites in Hinsdale."
The apartments matter too. Tortorello estimated that downtown has only 20 to 25 apartments, most of them vintage and "kind of tucked away." The Papenhausen unit and the four new one-bedrooms add five more, roughly a fifth to a quarter of his estimated total. He also noted that many downtown buildings owned by the same families for decades have been changing hands, and that rents will rise as buildings are upgraded.
The Fall Calendar Runs Straight Through These Blocks
The next two weeks of downtown events cover the storefronts above:
- Thursday, Oct. 15. The Hinsdale Chamber of Commerce hosts a ribbon cutting for Herbal Touch Wellness & Spa, on the second floor of 10 E. Hinsdale Ave. The event runs 11 a.m. to 7 p.m., and the ribbon is cut at noon.
- Saturday, Oct. 17. The Hinsdale Fall Sidewalk Sale runs 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. on downtown streets.
- Saturday, Oct. 24. The Village's free Fall Family Fest runs 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. at Hinsdale Middle School and downtown, with trick-or-treating at participating downtown businesses during the same hours.
Fall Family Fest has the most moving parts. The first 500 participants get a free pumpkin. Costume contest entrants check in at the Chamber of Commerce table between 11:30 a.m. and 1 p.m. The day also includes inflatables, crafts, food and entertainment. The Village hosts it with the Hinsdale Public Library, the Hinsdale Chamber of Commerce, The Community House and The Hinsdalean, and Bomba & Mancini is the named sponsor.
With the pumpkins capped at 500 and costume check-in closing at 1 p.m., the early part of the window is the busiest. Families working their way down Washington Street toward First will pass Toni's under its new owners and the Fairfield buildings mid-renovation.
Two Openings Downtown Is Still Waiting On
Two other new businesses have been announced, and as of this week neither has a confirmed opening.
Humble Patty is a smashburger and soft-serve spot planned for 50 S. Garfield Ave., the former Dips & Dogs space. According to the June 9 meeting minutes, the Village Board approved the exterior and site plan and made the certificate of occupancy conditional on a safety barrier. In spring and early summer, Patch reported an August target and The Hinsdalean said "by Labor Day." The Hinsdale Journal noted on June 23 that the storefront had been empty for five years and gave only a general 2026 target. Both dates have passed, and no local report has confirmed an opening.
Hometown Coffee and Juice was picked for the train-station space at 25 E. Hinsdale Ave. In April, its owners told The Hinsdalean they aimed to open by the end of the year. No update has followed.
Check with each business before planning a stop around it. If Humble Patty opens in time, it would bring the quick-bite option Tortorello says downtown lacks, a block from the patio he has in mind.
December Comes Next
Toni's owners called the fourth quarter their next hurdle, and the holiday calendar shows why. Here are the dates:
| Date | Event | Time | Where |
|---|---|---|---|
| Friday, Dec. 4 | 60th Annual Christmas Walk | 5 to 7 p.m. | Downtown Hinsdale |
| Sunday, Dec. 6 | Winter Wonderland | 9 a.m. to noon | Katherine Legge Memorial Park, 5901 S. County Line Road |
| Saturday, Dec. 12 | Hinsdale for the Holidays | 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. | Burlington Park |
The Chamber's Christmas Walk lists Santa, Santa's Village, the tree-lighting ceremony, a holiday train and a carousel. Winter Wonderland requires preregistration and costs $20 for residents and $25 for nonresidents. Hinsdale for the Holidays is free and includes Santa, carriage rides and gingerbread-cookie decorating.
This is the 60th Christmas Walk, and it will be the first under the new ownership of a bakery that has been part of downtown for 32 years.
When downtown buildings that one family owned for decades start selling, nearby homeowners often wonder what that means for their own property. The Cobb Team has followed downtown Hinsdale and the western suburbs for more than thirty years, and we're glad to share what we're seeing. Christopher Cobb can put together a free home valuation that reflects how your part of town is changing.